Troubleshooting FAQs (from old site)
|A wonderful resource has been published in the PA TIC program. Read their Aquarium Resource Guide, put together by their agency scientists and TIC coordinators. |
Join the TIC/SIC National Google Group!
This group is a great forum for questions, discussions, and announcements about everything Trout or Salmon in the Classroom! Simply apply for membership with your Google ID. Don’t have a Google ID? You can use your standard email address (@ any domain) as your login name.
Problems with tank and trout can come up at any time during the year. Below are a number of frequently asked questions that may address your concerns. Frequently asked questions:
What if I come in to school many trout have died/look sick?
Any time you have loss of trout or your fish look lethargic, swimming sideways, etc – WATER CHANGE! Water changes remove toxic ammonia and nitrites. Initially, do a 50% water change with treated or dechlorinated water and stop feeding your fish. Monitor your chemistry daily. If ammonia and/or nitrites are still an issue, continue doing up to 20% water changes daily until situation resolves. Add as many airstones to your tank as possible. The more O2 the better able your bacterial colony is at conversion of ammonia and nitrites. Feed fish very little, only as much as they can eat in a minute. Vacuum out any uneaten food.
It is vital that your tank establishes a healthy bacterial colony to move through the Nitrogen Cycle. The bacteria convert fish waste and extra food (ammonia) to nitrites and then nitrates.
Are leaks a problem? How can I prevent leaks?
Once a chiller system is assembled, it is unlikely that a leak will develop. However, physical contact with the system could damage connections, particularly tugging on tubes. For this reason, students should not touch chiller hardware without supervision. A serious leak will pump the entire contents of the tank onto the ground within a very short time.
What should I do if my chiller system starts to leak?
If there is a leak in any external part such as the tubes for the chiller, turn off and unplug all electronic tank systems. A large volume of water may be contained in the chiller and chiller tubes, so it might help stop a leak if the tubes are removed from the tank and placed in a 5 gallon bucket. It is important that the leak be fixed as soon as possible so that the chiller can continue to keep the water cool.
Can I fix leaks on my own?
The assembly of the chiller system is straightforward, so fixing it is quite possible without assistance. Simply unscrew the connection, and make sure that it is not cracked or damaged in anyway. Next, reassemble the leaking connection carefully. You can use a tool to tighten any connection, but do not force any plastic parts as they will crack under excessive strain.
What happens if there is a power failure? How much time do I have?
It is important that the fish see as stable a water temperature as possible. Short downtimes, of an hour or two at a time, probably will not harm the fish or change tank temperatures by any great amount. However, lost power during the night or over a weekend (or worse still, a long vacation) will likely be fatal to the fish.
What should I do if the power must be turned off?
All individuals such as custodians, who may turn the power on and off, should be informed that the trout system needs constant power. If there is no way to prevent it, for construction for example, it would be best to cycle the power. This means running the chiller for two hours on, then two off. This is better than simply letting the tank sit all day without power.
Can I keep eggs or fish in a household refrigerator?
Refrigerators are not an acceptable substitute for the tank environment. Because most refrigerators operate between 35 and 40 degrees, they are far colder than the tank.
What do I do with my eggs or fish in an emergency?
In an emergency, eggs can be preserved by placing them in a cool dark place, with an ice pack and thermometer. Careful regulation in the amount of ice should make it possible to keep the eggs around 50 degrees. Do not add ice to the eggs directly; apply to the outside of the egg container. Ice water may be dirty, and the rapid melting from immersion would cause sudden temperature changes that might do more harm than good.
With fish, particularly large fish, the only option in an emergency is to add ice to the tank. The best way to do this is to freeze large plastic containers of water, such as soda bottles, and add them to the tank. When creating these, do not fill them to the top as the ice that forms takes up more space than the liquid. Clean ice packs can also work, or sealed plastic bags of regular ice. It is possible to regulate temperature by adding or taking away ice in this way. Do not add regular tap water ice cubes directly to the tank unless there is no other option–this ice likely has chlorine in it, which can harm the fish. Some teachers create tank-water ice cubes, in anticipation of an emergency.
A 5 gallon bucket would be a good choice for holding fish in an emergency, if there is a problem with the tank.
It is best to prevent any such problems and carefully maintain the tank environment. The priority in an emergency is getting the tank environment back to normal, no emergency procedure can replace the stability of a working tank.
What should I do if there is a serious leak while I am away, and the tank is almost empty when I return?
If there is a serious leak, during the night or weekend, almost all of the tank water may be pumped out. It is unlikely for the tank system to fail on its own, but it is important to be ready in the event of such an accident. If the fish are in very shallow water, and the chiller is no longer working because the pump is running dry, it is important to carefully repair the tank system environment. First, you should fix the leak. Next, add enough cold tap water (preferably treated with a tap-water-safe compound from a pet/aquarium store). This gets the chiller working again; you will probably need just a few gallons. Add this water slowly, and try to make this water around the same temperature as the tank water (which might be warmer by now).
Once there is enough water to have the chiller run, you should let the tank reach 50 degrees again. There may not be enough water for the filter to run, so it should be unplugged to prevent damage to the motor. The bubbler must be used during this process if possible.
At this point, begin to age as much tap water as possible in every clean container you might have. Starting the next morning (the fish should be fine in 4 inches of water for the night provided the chiller works), slowly add the aged tap water. If you can, it would be best to add only a few cups at a time, many times during the day. Continue to do this until the tank is about half full. Once the tank is half full, you can add the aged water a few gallons a day. Continue to make new aged water as you use it, and because this is an emergency situation you only have to age the water 24 hours if 48 hours is too hard. Do this until the tank is back up to normal levels. Don’t forget to reconnect the system filter, and resume normal maintenance procedures including water changes.
The idea throughout this process is to make the changes for the trout as subtle as possible, once they’re back at 50 degrees. Large swings in temperature and/or water quality can stress them out and increase mortality.
How can I inform custodians, or other teachers, about what to do if there is an emergency while I am away?
It is a good idea to give custodians some basic information about the requirements of your tank. For example, it is important that custodians know that your tank always needs electricity. It would be most helpful to place a sheet of paper (in a visible location) describing emergency procedures. This might include contact numbers, and basic advice on what to do to stabilize the tank if there is a chiller failure, leak, or power outage. You might want to prepare a frozen soda bottle of water to use in a chiller emergency, and then include the location of this ice and how to use it in your emergency procedure sheet. An example is below:
Tank Emergency Procedure:
In the event of a power outage, leak, or refrigeration system failure, or any other tank problem, please contact me:______________________
If you cannot reach me, please try calling:
In the event of a power outage: The trout in this tank need cold water to survive, and the chiller next to/under the tank maintains their temperature. If possible, the electricity to this tank should be turned on again. If the electricity must be off because of maintenance or construction for more than a few hours, please contact me as soon as possible. If I cannot be contacted in time, please place the frozen soda bottle of ice in the tank to help keep it cool. Even with the ice, the tank needs electricity as soon as possible.
In the event of a serious leak: A serious leak can be stopped by turning off all electrical parts of the tank system, or unplugging them. Any leaking tubes should be placed back in the tank or in a bucket. After all the water is cleaned up, the source of the leak can be fixed. This will probably be loose tubes or tubes which fell out of the tank. If there are more than 4 inches of water left in the tank, the fish can survive. Please do not add any water to the tank if this is the case. Lots of tap water, or water that is too warm, can kill the fish. If there is very little water in the tank, please add only enough cold tap water to let the pump work again. If the leak is fixed, please turn on all devices before you leave.
Do I need goldfish to start my nitrogen cycle? If I start late, should I use more goldfish?
At this time, it is no longer recommended that educators use goldfish to help “break in” the tank system. All systems should be installed with additives such as Biozyme or Stress Zyme which help create a suitable water environment.
Can I mix species of trout?
No, the different trout species may not be compatible. The risk of cannibalism among young fish (under ½ year of age) is greatly increased with species mixing.
Why are so many of my eggs or fish dying?
Death is a natural part of fish development. Everyone should expect to lose eggs and fish. The exact survival rate is highly variable and based on many factors. A sudden spike in mortality can indicate a tank problem. It is also worth noting that there are two naturally high-mortality periods, first during the egg stage and then again when the trout first learn to feed. Some fish never learn to feed and simply starve.
What is a normal death rate?
Death rates are different from one stage to the next. With green eggs, a large percentage are expected to die. With eyed eggs, a higher survival rate is expected. The loss of most of your eyed eggs does suggest a problem. As the fish hatch, and age further, survival rates should improve. By the time fish are free swimming and have learned to eat, death should be an uncommon event. Losing many free swimming fish, above all else, is a sign that the tank environment is not healthy. As they grow, fish produce more waste, so cleaning may be needed more often.
Most of my fish died in the first month, is this common?
One of the most common times for massive fish death is in the first month. Because eggs and young fish are more easily stressed, there is a high risk for death as a result of fungus, changes in water quality, or large swings in temperature. It is important that water changes and cleaning be practiced before the fish arrive, and that this process is maintained on schedule. Most catastrophic die offs seem to start with a missed cleaning day or weekend. By the time cleaning resumes, the damage may have already been done.
What do I do with dead fish or dead eggs?
It is very important that dead eggs, dead fish, and decaying waste matter (discarded food for example) are removed as soon as possible. This should be done at least once a day, and even more often during critical periods or as needed. This process alone is very important in keeping the remaining fish alive. Poor cleaning is very often the root cause of excessive fish death.
Why are my fish or eggs dying at an abnormally high rate?
Poor water quality, as a result of insufficient cleaning or water changes is among the most serious threats to fish health. It is essential that water changes of 10-20% per week (more as the trout get older and bigger) be maintained, with aged or treated tap water to remove chlorine. Other causes of fish death might be temperature fluctuations, lack of aeration, and chemical exposure. High ammonia concentrations can result in sudden fish death.
How sensitive are the fish to temperature changes?
For best results, the trout should be exposed to the most stable temperature possible, as close as possible to the ideal. Fish can handle small fluctuations of one or two degrees, but sudden changes of almost any scale will be stressful. Changes of 5 degrees or more are a serious threat to trout survival particularly if they are sudden.
How can I help keep a stable tank temperature?
It is important that the chiller always be on and set to the appropriate temperature. Also, because water changes introduce warmer water into the tank, please limit these changes to 10% of your tank volume at any one time. The best way to change water is to change a small amount (2% of the tank volume) every day of the school week, plus a large (10%) water change once a week. 1 gallon plastic jugs (used for bottled water) would work great for this. An assembly line of 5 jugs would allow water to be aged first (with the caps removed), then used every 5 days. The use of insulation will help the chiller maintain a stable temperature, but may not be needed. Larger tanks will also help protect fish because they have more water to buffer any changes.
Why is the airstone needed?
Aeration of the tank is an important part of simulating a stream environment and is essential to the Nitrogen Cycle to convert ammonia. We recommend having at least two bubblers to aid your bacterial colony in completing the Nitrogen Cycle. The stream environment is not only cold, but constantly moving and constantly mixed with air. Because of this, it is important that filters, air-stones, and the chiller pump all operate well. The filter on the chiller pump, the intake on the tank filter, and the surface of the air-stones should all be clean and free of debris.
Should students wash hands before touching tank water?
Students may wish to clean their hands before working in or around the tank without using soap. Simply use warm tap water for this, and for cleaning of other objects like nets and the bucket. This will help keep chemicals and dirt from getting into the tank. Moisturizers and other skincare products might also harm fish. It is very important that no soap enter the tank environment, because soap may harm or kill fish even in small concentrations.
Should students wash up after contact with tank water?
Yes. While tank water is not particularly hazardous to students, they should clean their hands with soap and warm water. Please do not use soap until all tank work is done.
Some of my hatched fish are not eating – Some of my fish are deformed. Is this normal?
Yes. During the growth process, some fish will die. Some fish may survive initially only to die later because they never begin to eat. Other fish will be deformed, and very often will also die as a result of this. This is a natural part of fish reproduction. It is not normal, however, for very many or most of the fish to die. If this is the case, there may be a problem with the tank environment.
My fish have hatched, what should I do with the eggs?
The discarded egg shells will decompose naturally in time. If they appear to be hosting fungal growth, they should be removed and disposed of. Just as with living eggs, they might turn opaque white, or may take on a fuzzy appearance. If this is the case, please remove them.
When should the trout be allowed out of the hatching basket?
It is generally agreed that trout should remain in the basket as long as possible, even after some start to jump out on their own. Once the trout are all able to swim freely, and are strong enough to navigate the currents of the tank, you can release them into the tank. After the trout have been actively feeding for a week or two, they should be nearly strong enough.
How do I let the trout out of the basket when it is time?
You can gently remove the basket from the sides of the tank and slowly lower it to the bottom of the tank. You can let the trout swim out from here. This allows some trout to remain in the protection of the basket for a few days. You may also gently tip the basket as well to remove them, but it is best to be as gentle as possible. Please make sure that the basket is empty before removing it from the tank. Don’t forget to cover the filter intake and pump intake to protect small fish from the powerful suction these tank components generate.
My alevin are very active, and are pushing other fish into the corners of the basket. What does this behavior suggest? Should I be feeding these fish more?
This type of activity is normal in trout. In this stage, young trout prefer dark corners. It may be helpful to put some screen material over the basket to reduce the amount of light these fish are exposed to. UV light can be harmful to eggs and alevin. Fish at this age do not need food at all. When beginning to feed, at the end of the alevin stage, please start with small amounts.
Trout are being sucked into the filter, how can I prevent this?
Young fish might be small enough to get pulled into the tank filter, or be hurt by the suction it creates. If possible, please place some material like plastic netting, panty hose, or cheesecloth over the filter intake using rubber bands. This cover will catch a lot of debris and will need to be rinsed often. It can be removed once the fish are large and active enough to avoid the filter.
What is an ammonia spike? What can I do about it?
An ammonia spike is one example of a chemical imbalance in the tank environment. These are serious threats to fish health. The tank filter and its bacterial population help reduce problems like this, but they cannot work alone. The best way to prevent any chemical imbalances in the tank is to regularly clean the tank, and change the water. All debris such as food, waste, and dead fish should be removed as soon as possible. Water changes of 10-20% per week are required and should not be skipped. There is no replacement for regular cleaning and water changes.
One strategy for dealing with climbing ammonia levels is to turn off the filter and add a pro-bacterial product such as StressZyme. AFTER TWO HOURS, turn the filter back on, and proceed as normal. Test the water in the coming days to ensure that the ammonia is converting to nitrates. Continue with water changes as planned.
Can I use ammonia removal grains to prevent ammonia spikes?
While they are not needed, you may chose to use ammonia removal grains to help regulate ammonia levels in the tank. If you do so, please follow the directions on the container, and always err on the side of too few rather than too many. Ammonia grains are, however, not a replacement for regular water changes and cleaning of the tank. Even with the use of grains, a 10-20% per week water change must be maintained.
My tank is coated with a green slime. What is this? What should I do?
Green films or slime may indicate algal growth. This will not necessarily hurt your trout, and some teachers leave it growing. Many, however, choose to remove algal growth. It can be mechanically cleaned by using an aquarium (or soap free) sponge or similar tool. Also, to prevent further algal growth, it is best to limit the amount of light entering the tank. The use of foam or paper to cover the sides of the tank will help. The tank should never be in direct sunlight at any time. This may also indicate that the UV sterilizer is not functioning properly. Please be sure to change the bulb every year. Even if an older bulb produces blue light, it may not be creating UV light anymore.
I am using the same tank system I had last year, what do I need to do to make it ready this year?
At the beginning of each year, to prepare for the next set of trout, you should clean all parts of the tank system with warm water. Please do not use soap on any part of the tank. You should also replace any disposable filter parts, and install a new UV bulb.
The water in my tank is cloudy. What should I do?
Cloudy water probably indicates an excess in decaying matter. This may be from dead fish, leftover food, or a problem with the filtration. Carefully conducting regular water changes, as well as cleaning the tank of all solid material, is the best way to fight this. Make sure the filter is functioning properly, and that water is flowing out of it. Clean filter components if needed, but do not use soap or any chemical cleaners. Carbon filter packs should be replaced every year. If fish are not eating all provided food, you may reduce the amount given until they are able to eat it all. Excess food after 10 minutes should be removed and discarded.
How should I conduct water changes? What is the right amount of water to change?
Water changes are an important part of tank maintenance. Improper water changes can cause fish stress or even death. It is best to change about 10-20% of tank volume every week with tap water aged for more than 48 hours (so that the chlorine in the water has had time to dissipate).
While this might mean simply conducting one 5 gallon change a week for a 50 gallon tank, it would be far better to do 1 gallon changes every school day of the week in addition to the bigger change once a week. Five plastic milk or water jugs are perfect for this. If the top of each jug is cut off, this will aid chlorine dissipation. An assembly line of water can be made, where the jugs are aged several days before use and are then refilled and placed at the back of the line. This reduces the sudden change in tank temperature as room temperature water is added.
What happens to the fish next?
The fish will be released into a watershed stream or river. Students can participate in the transportation of fish to their new habitat as well as the release process. It is hard to determine the survival rates for released trout, but full grown fish have been recovered and genetically linked to trout raised in the classroom. However, in general, TIC is not a stocking program, but rather an educational program. The true value of raising and releasing trout lies in the process.
How tight should plastic parts be?
Plastic parts need to be tightened by hand. They should be as tight as possible without risking damage.
Is it safe to use metal tools on plastic parts?
The use of metal tools is OK when great care is taken. It is more important that parts be screwed in place in the proper position; no amount of force can replace good alignment.
What tool should I use to tighten the worm gear clamps?
Some ring clamps come with thumb screws that allow tightening without tools. Others only require a screw driver. These should be tight, but should not be forced. It is possible that plastic parts could be broken with too much force.
Does it matter where I put the chiller?
Yes, the location of the chiller (above or below the tank) may alter the water pressure and flow rate in the system. While the pump can handle just about any arrangement, placing the chiller on the floor below an elevated tank will slightly reduce water flow and pressure. It is more important that tubes be free of kinks or excessive bends, so adding length to relax tubing is fine. The best place to put the chiller is directly below or to one side of the tank. It is best to put the chiller as close to level with the tank, but it is not required.
My tap water is discolored, is this ok?
All water will have some color, most often a faint green or white color. Tap water that is not acceptable might appear very cloudy or may have a strong chemical smell. If this is the case, an alternate source of water should be considered.
How do I know if my water is safe for trout?
Most tap water will be acceptable for use in this tank system. After a break in period of at least one week, there will be plenty of time for chlorine to dissipate, and for particulate matter to be filtered out. Unless your water appears to be totally unacceptable, it is probably safe for trout. The break-in period is an important part of this, so being safe after a week does not mean that water directly from the tap would be safe for fish.
How should I assemble the hatching basket?
The hatching basket is designed to protect very young fish from physical harm. The plastic frame should be secure, and free of sharp edges or scrap plastic. The net is supposed to be placed loosely around the outside of the plastic frame. The net should be loose because this helps make the edges less prone to damage fish which become stuck. To avoid this problem entirely, some teachers prefer to place the net inside the frame and then secure it at each corner with needle and thread. Ensure that the net will not fall off, and is free from holes or damage.
Should the net be on the inside or outside of the hatching basket?
While the manufacturer designed this net to be placed around the outside of the plastic frame, it can be improved by placing the net on the inside. This makes for an even safer environment for the young fish. Monofilament or twist ties can help secure the net to the inside. The net can be loose, but should not float up as this could let the eggs fall out of the basket.
What tools are needed for tank installation?
The only tools needed for tank installation are a screwdriver, knife or pair of scissors, and pliers to tighten any connections if needed. You may also need a clean 5 gallon bucket to assist in filling the tank and water changes. This can be purchased at any hardware store. Please rinse the bucket first and then do not use this bucket for anything other than tank water.
Do I need to age tank water before first filling the system?
No, the break in period will age the water before fish are introduced.
The tubing is very hard to fit over the plastic tank parts, what should I do?
If tubing doesn’t fit over parts, it might help to dip the end of the tub in hot water. Very hot water works best.
Tubing can be carefully stretched by heating the ends, and then inserting a rigid object like a pair of scissors into the end. This applies pressure to the end and stretches it a small amount. Excessive force can break the tube end.
Tight tubing generally will fit, but it might require some time and patience.
Should I get a lid for my tank?
Yes, it is better to cover the tank with some material which can prevent objects from falling in, and provide the reduced light levels that fish prefer. Foam, screen, and plastic have all been used as lid materials with success. Purchased lids for the tank can also work, but because many of these include lights, it is important that the light feature not be used.
Does my tank need insulation?
Many tank systems have worked without insulation. However, insulation will provide a darker, more stable environment for the fish. Insulation will reduce the amount of work needed to maintain the water temperature, saving electricity and limiting the amount of time the chiller will be operational. In addition, insulation will reduce condensation which could pose a problem in the summer.
What kind of insulation can I use?
There are many materials which can help insulate the tank. The most popular is foam sheet material, available at any home repair – industrial hardware store. Two layers of bubble wrap, the shipping material, also would make a good insulator. For best results, cover the bottom of the tank as well. Many other materials can work including plastic, wood, or cardboard.
Where do I position the airstone aka bubbler?
The airstone aeration system produces a large volume of bubbles. These bubbles can interfere with the filter operation by filling the motor with air and causing it to “air lock” and fail. For this reason, there should be at least 4 inches between the airstone and the filter.